Roofing Scout

What are roofing shingles?

Ty
Written by:
Ty
Mar 26, 2025
Share article:

Are you thinking about putting a new roof on your home? You might be wondering about the type of material to use. Many homeowners choose shingles as their go-to choice. Roofing shingles are an excellent material that can provide essential protection for your home and boost its aesthetic appeal.

 

However, with a wide variety of shingle types available, you will want to know their differences, benefits, and costs to make the best decision for your next project.

 

At RoofingScout, we are here to help. We'll walk you through everything you need to know about roofing shingles from the types available to maintenance tips and cost expectations.

 

shutterstock_2447925993.jpg

 

 

What are roofing shingles?

 

In the United States, roofing shingles are a popular material used on residential properties. They are small, flat, rectangular pieces of roofing material. These shingles can comprise several materials, including asphalt, wood, slate, and metal. When they're placed on the roof, they will overlap each other to cover the entire surface.

 

Many people choose these materials because they're affordable, versatile for any roof style, and easy to install. Along with that, they're durable and visually appealing. No matter your home's architectural design, you can find shingles in various colors, styles, and textures to match your style preferences.

 

Types of roofing shingles

 

Generally, you can find three types of shingles: 3-tab, architectural, and luxury. They each have their own unique features, advantages, and price range. Let's look at the basics of these shingle types:

 

  • Three-tab shingles are the most cost-effective choice on the market. These shingles have three tabs per shingle, hence the name. Three-tab shingles provide your home with a uniform look. You will usually find them made with asphalt.
  • Architectural shingles are sometimes known either as dimensional or laminate shingles. These are an upgrade from 3-tab shingles in both quality and appearance. The shingles are thicker, and they have a layered design that adds some depth and dimension to the roof. With that, these shingles can give your roof the look of expensive materials without the costs.
  • One of the top-of-the-line options is luxury shingles. These designer shingles are some of the highest-quality materials available. Often, these shingles will look like natural materials, such as slate or cedar shakes. Luxury shingles give a high-end look without the added costs and maintenance.

 

When choosing a roofing material, consider their class rating. These shingles are rated based on their impact resistance:

 

  • Class 1: Minimal impact resistance
  • Class 2: Moderate protection from small impacts
  • Class 3: Substantial impact resistance from mid-level impacts
  • Class 4: The highest level of impact resistance, protecting against larger impacts, including hail

 

Manufacturers determine shingles' classes based on how well one holds up to a steel ball dropped on it from various heights. For example, a class 1 shingle can withstand the impact of a 1.25-inch steel ball dropped two times from 12 feet up. If the shingle sustains any damage other than dents or some loss of surface materials, that's considered "broken" for the purposes of the test.

 

It's important to keep in mind that class 1 shingles aren't inherently better than class 4 shingles—class 4 shingles are often made thicker, and the materials vary, so it's always a good idea to consult with a professional roofer when choosing which class to go with for your roofing project.

 

You may also see shingles rated by class for their fire protection ability. Fire safety ratings range from class A (the most resistant to fire exposure) to class C (the least). Similarly, manufacturers rate shingles based on wind resistance as well. The wind resistance classification scale starts at class A, referring to shingles able to withstand 60-mph winds for two hours, and ends at class F, which refers to shingles that are able to withstand 110-mph winds for that same two-hour time span.

 

Lastly, some insurance providers offer lower premiums on homes that use higher-class shingles. Because multiple factors go into determining a premium, the actual amount can vary between providers and covered parties. However, the discount (or credit) will vary depending on the class of material used, with the lowest incentives for class 1 shingles.

 

Cost considerations for roofing shingles

 

In all projects, costs are the major deciding factor between materials. If you are looking for a less expensive option, the cost for asphalt shingles is around $4.25 to $8.25 per square foot while architectural shingles are $12.25 per square foot. Since luxury shingle materials can vary, so can the costs. They can range from $6 to $30 per square foot.

 

Also, consider the labor costs. Asphalt shingles are straightforward to install while luxury ones may require more specialized tools and skilled roofers to complete the job, adding to the costs.

 

While these are general prices, other factors can always affect the entire cost of your project.

 

shutterstock_74756995 - 3Tab.jpg

Roofing types pros and cons

 

All these materials serve the same purpose of protecting your roof, but there are a few benefits and disadvantages that you should know.

 

3-tab shingles

Pros

  • Least expensive option
  • Uniform design provides a clean and straightforward look suitable for various home styles
  • Easy installation
  • Easy replacement

Cons

  • Less resistant to severe storms
  • May be more difficult to find than sturdier options

Best uses

 

  • Areas where inclement weather is less frequent
  • Roofing for the budget-conscious

 

 

Architectural shingles

Pros

  • Layered design for a more stylized appearance
  • Help insulate roof, lowering energy costs
  • Deflect light, keeping your roof cooler
  • Better waterproofing ability

Cons

  • More expensive than 3-tab shingles
  • Longer installation time

Best uses

 

  • Areas where heat from the sun is a particular issue
  • Buyers who want an intermediary between 3-tab and luxury

 

 

Luxury shingles

Pros

  • Mimic other material types, giving you a wider range of styles
  • Sturdier
  • Better energy efficiency for your home
  • Large variety of shapes and colors

Cons

  • The most expensive asphalt shingle option
  • Can be heavy, making them unsuitable for homes where stability is an issue

Best uses

 

  • Long-term investment (equity, home sales, etc.)
  • Homes where budget isn't an issue

How to choose the right roofing shingles

 

When it comes time to find the right shingles for your home, you need to take into consideration several factors. These include the following.

 

Weather resistance

 

All roofing shingles can shield your home from wind and rain, but some do better than others in harsh environments. If you live in an area with extreme weather, you need to keep this in mind. Architectural and luxury shingles offer higher resistance to wind, hail, and heavy rainfall, for example.

 

Energy efficiency

 

Energy-efficient shingles can help regulate your home's temperature, reducing heating and cooling costs. Architectural and luxury shingles are generally the most energy-efficient, offering more insulation and the ability to reflect more heat away from the home.

 

Aesthetic appeal

 

This factor is entirely subjective—it all depends on your personal aesthetic as well as that of your HOA when applicable. Asphalt shingles provide a uniform, classic look that is perfect for those who want a plainer style. Architectural and luxury shingles add more dimension, and they come in a wide array of colors and shapes. For a rustic look, you can even find ones that resemble slate or wood.

 

Cost-effectiveness

 

In essence, look at what is most feasible for your budget. Three-tab shingles are the most economical up front, and they're one of the most common options. Architectural and luxury shingles are more cost-prohibitive, but they offer more value over the long term through energy efficiency and overall durability. The actual savings you see will vary from house to house and climate to climate, however, making no one option better than the others.

Roofing shingles: maintenance and longevity

 

If you take the right steps, you can maximize the life span of the shingles and make sure your home remains protected. By taking time to conduct regular maintenance, such as checking for damage or cleaning up debris, these shingles can last for many years to come. 

 

shutterstock_2451527891 - architectural.jpg

 

 

Common roofing shingle issues

 

However, despite this upkeep, roof shingles will not last forever. In some cases, they can even develop a few issues. Curling is of particular concern with some asphalt shingles. Due to age, poor ventilation, or improper installation, they can curl, leading to reduced protection and potential leaks. Even exposure to extreme temperatures and weather conditions can cause shingles to crack. Any type of asphalt shingle can lose granules over time, even luxury varieties, which can leave your roof vulnerable to damage.

 

How often should you replace your roofing shingles?

 

Unfortunately, there is no direct answer since it can depend on the type of maintenance, environmental factors, and type of shingle used on your roof. However, as a standard guideline, you can expect to replace these materials within these timelines:

 

  • 3-tab shingles: 20 years
  • Architectural shingles: 25-30 years
  • Luxury shingles: 30-50 years

 

Whether you're looking for an affordable choice, a little balance between durability and price, or a luxurious material, there are plenty of options for you. You just need to decide which one will give you the biggest bang for your budget. When you need help with a current or future project, remember that RoofingScout is your trusted partner for all things roofing.

 

Frequently Asked Questions
What are impact-resistant roofing shingles?
These roofing shingles can withstand damage from hail, falling branches, and other debris. You will find them with a Class 4 rating from Underwriters Laboratories (UL). That is the highest rating for impact resistance. They're made with stronger materials, or they have a reinforced backing that absorbs impact.
How long do roofing shingles last?
Three-tab shingles will generally last around 15-30 years depending on maintenance. Architectural shingles have a slightly higher floor, with an average life span of anywhere from 25-30 years. In turn, luxury shingles will often last 30 years at minimum with good care.
How much are roofing shingles?
Though the final pricing will vary depending on labor and other factors, you'll generally find that 3-tab shingles can run anywhere between $3.70 and $8.75 per square foot. Architectural shingles have some overlap, though the highest end of the spectrum lies at around $12.25 per square foot. Luxury shingles generally scale up from there.
What is the best type of roof shingles?
This varies greatly depending on your needs. Asphalt is the most common type of shingle you'll find, with the basic kind being ideal for those with budgetary concerns. Architectural and luxury shingles offer more protection from storms and other inclement weather, but they come with their own cons as well.